I can see quite a few people prefer xps 15 as it has bigger screen, 4K resolution, quad cores, and even cheaper than surface book.
but, xps 15 is not detachable, it does not have pen, it's heavier, and most important, it is not surface
I think in that other thread the desire of larger screen than SP3 and (main home computer) + (portable computer) use cases with options of Surface Book only, or XPS 15 + SP3 is how the XPS 15 presented as a good option when paired with the Surface. Outside of that scenario and context it's a different story. As your only computer XPS 15 has tradeoffs but so does Surface Book. The combination of XPS 15 + a Surface makes for a powerful and flexible alternative.I can see quite a few people prefer xps 15 as it has bigger screen, 4K resolution, quad cores, and even cheaper than surface book.
but, xps 15 is not detachable, it does not have pen, it's heavier, and most important, it is not surface
Having both XPS 15 + Surface seems odd to me. Seems like an admission that Microsoft failed. The point of the Surface is to merge the two form factors (tablet and laptop). If you're going to use two devices anyway, maybe it makes sense to have a real tablet and not a 2 in 1 to go with the XPS.
If screen size is a major issue perhaps docking with an external monitor/keyboard may be best.
Having both XPS 15 + Surface seems odd to me. Seems like an admission that Microsoft failed. The point of the Surface is to merge the two form factors (tablet and laptop). If you're going to use two devices anyway, maybe it makes sense to have a real tablet and not a 2 in 1 to go with the XPS.
If screen size is a major issue perhaps docking with an external monitor/keyboard may be best.
I think in that other thread the desire of larger screen than SP3 and (main home computer) + (portable computer) use cases with options of Surface Book only, or XPS 15 + SP3 is how the XPS 15 presented as a good option when paired with the Surface. Outside of that scenario and context it's a different story. As your only computer XPS 15 has tradeoffs but so does Surface Book. The combination of XPS 15 + a Surface makes for a powerful and flexible alternative.
True, that will do. However, I don't need 15'' screen for my laptop, if I need a bigger screen, I simply use an external 24'' ones. so I am happy with SB's 13'' screen.