Here's an easy example. Open up 5 tabs in IE and then try to close each one.. There is a slight lag as you press to close each tab...
Mine close as soon as I touch the x.
Go to a website like espn.com and try to zoom in on the headlines on the far right. The clear type text effect takes a second or two to work. It is more noticeable when opening apps like News, Sports, Finance, or zooming in on pictures. When you scroll slowly, the text stutters as well because the clear type needs a second to work.. On the iPad you can actually have one finger on the screen and scroll with the other finger without distorting the text.
I can use a finger and the screen and scroll text while reading without issue. When reflowing text it does take a second to clear but literally just a second. Apple does this differently and I would say it is quicker for the clearing of text. I have seen it discussed where there are other trade offs (I believe it is that more of the page is checker boarded because it isn't loaded) but either way, it is ok if Apple flat out does this best even without compromise. There is nothing wrong with somebody being better than the others at text reflow. What the Surface offers isn't horrible or even substandard but not the best either.
Regarding the forum bug, why is it only a bug in IE and not in Safari? If the Surface only runs IE then that's an issue with the tablet. Same thing with other websites like Redfin, Zillow that don't work properly. You can say that websites aren't optimized for the new IE, but ultimately we suffer when MS only provides one browser option...
This is strictly a site compatibility and web administrator issue. It isn't fully compatible with IE's standards and that isn't the fault of MS or IE they can't control how others set up their own websites.
The camera is also not up to par,
I agree they should have been better than they are (they are below average) but for me the front camera works fine for skyping and I don't use it for anything else so it wouldn't have mattered
the screen resolution is last generation,
Not sure how you figure this. You must be referring to the RT screen. The pixel density is enough to be crisp and clear. While I would prefer a higher PPI in the range of 200+ the clear type does a good job of boosting the perceived clarity near this range. The bonus is that in desktop mode things are usable without scaling issues. The resolution chosen is a standard resolution and makes a very good compromise for what the RT needs to do.
and the volume is too low...
Have you applied the updates and made the appropriate adjustments in settings? The Surface is on par with other tablets for volume.
These are all hardware issues that should not exist in a premium tablet.
Only screen resolution, camera and to some degree the sound (though small speakers even laptop size have always had this compromise) are hardware issues. The rest are software issues. This is also a first generation device with first generation areas that can be improved. Again it doesn't have so much to do with being premium as being new. The screen and camera resolutions are well publicized, if you need a higher resolution than this isn't the tablet your are looking for regardless of being "premium".
With all that said, the Surface has many pros, but this thread is to identify gripes.
Yep these are all gripes but there are differences between gripes and personal preferences as well. One of these things has absolutely nothing to do with the Surface at all. There is always the next generation to look forward to and I am sure there will be faster processors, higher screen resolutions and better battery life
For a couple of the issues, if you are experiencing some lag you might want to make sure you are updated. If so and you are experiencing issues anyway you might want to try a refresh.
I am with the others though that the specs are well publicized and you know what you are getting. It isn't really a Surface issue but a self imposed gripe if you buy a certain screen resolution and then say it is too low. Gripes are things like the mail app, the power plug, the book marks in IE Modern, etc. As a first generation device and knowing what you are getting into it is really a good machine. It isn't perfect but there is nothing else that is either. Maybe I should open a constructive criticism thread instead