I came across this article about paper note taking being more effective in terms of comprehension, and it made me think of this thread:
http://www.npr.org/2015/05/27/40879...ign=npr&utm_term=nprnews&utm_content=20150527
My own experience with digital pen use goes back to Tablet PCs and my time as a sales engineer for Ricoh, a job I left a little over seven years ago. I used Tablet PCs to take literally thousands of notes on OneNote (yes, that long ago), and here's why:
- I wanted notes that could be easily searched. I had way too many prospects and customers generating copious amounts of notes to try to manage them all with paper. I also attended many meetings a day, some of which were followups, meaning I would have had to carry a portable filing cabinet around with me to make it all work.
Tablet PCs were excellent at converting handwriting to text in the background, which I only used for searching. To this day, I can pull up that OneNote file and search my notes for, say, "OCR required" and get every relevant note in seconds. That's powerful stuff.
- I liked to take notes by hand rather than typing because I needed to draw diagrams of business processes and workflows and such. I simply can't imagine how to do that without using a pen, unless I were to type my verbal notes and then draw diagrams on paper, which seems silly.
- I often took notes while walking around a business and observing. Obviously, that's easier with a Tablet PC (now Surface) tucked in my arm.
- Finally, and what was most interesting to me: I was meeting with prospects and customers. It was much less disruptive to hold a machine in my arm and take notes like I would with a pad of paper than set a clamshell notebook between me and the person/people I was meeting with and type. Having that screen between us just wasn't conducive to a positive, inviting atmosphere.
I think the same is likely true for students in classrooms, and many other instances.
Obviously, I'm a huge fan of digital pens. My handwriting is horrible and my drawing skills nonexistent, but OneNote still manages to read what I write and 10 years later I can still figure out what a prospect was asking for. That's pretty amazing stuff as far as I'm concerned.